The Law Firm of Frank Stanley, PC
Don’t Wait, Call Today
Local: 616-773-2702 / Toll Free: 1-877-459-8699
After Hours & Emergency Matters. No Charge for Initial Inquiry: 616-540-0007

Why mental competence matters in criminal law

In Michigan, a criminal trial cannot proceed if the defendant is mentally incapable of participating in his or her own defense. The defendant’s mental abilities are often in dispute at trial.

For example, the attorney for a Flint woman charged with arson in connection with a 2016 apartment fire says the woman has an IQ of 45 and is considered “extremely deficient” mentally. The woman has undergone a psychiatric evaluation, which the judge overseeing the case reviewed at a March 15 hearing, Mlive reports.

The woman is charged with first-degree arson and could face life in prison if convicted. Her attorney noted that the Michigan Center for Forensic Psychiatry declared his client competent to stand trial despite her IQ, saying the department “glassed over” relevant evidence of her mental state.

The defense lawyer asked the judge for extra time to conduct an independent investigation of the woman. The judge granted the motion, but declined to set bond, forcing the woman to remain in jail.

No trial can be called “fair” when the defendant is unable to communicate with his or her lawyer or understand the proceedings and the potential consequences. The competency requirement is meant to prevent the injustice of someone getting convicted of a crime simply because he or she was not able to mount a legitimate defense.

Everyone charged with a crime has the right to strong legal defense. Trying to take on the complexities of the criminal justice system by yourself will put you at a severe disadvantage, so make sure to call an experienced defense attorney as soon as possible after an arrest.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Email Us For A Response

How can we help you?

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

The Law Firm of Frank Stanley, PC
234 N. Division Ave.
Suite 400
Grand Rapids, MI 49503

Toll Free: 877-459-8699
Phone: 616-773-2702
Fax: 616-742-5689
Map & Directions